Are E-Books a Good Idea for the Science Class?

  • E-book
  • 29 October, 2017
  • 4 Comments

Teacher question:

 A colleague asked me about using e-books in high school science classes instead of textbooks. I like the idea that e-books might be more current and kids would likely read outside of class if they didn’t have to lug a huge book home. However, I remember reading something about the brain processing the reading of e-books differently than traditional texts. Do you know of any sound research on that?

Shanahan response:

I knew this question was coming.

  Back about 25 years ago or so, I just knew someone would ask me about such reading. So I conducted a small study.

  No, I didn’t do a real study. Not the kind of empirical investigation that I would publish in a journal or anything. I conducted a kind of personal investigation to gain some insights based on experience until real research existed on this topic.

  I knew someone would eventually want to know about digital reading so I “read” four books:

  • I read an adult novel silently (usually in bed just before sleep).
  • I read a children’s novel aloud to one of my daughters in the evening before her bedtime.
  • I listened to a recorded book in the car while driving to and from work.
  • I read a book online (Dracula from Project Guttenberg) on a computer (pads didn’t yet exist) usually over lunch.

  The point of engaging in these different kinds of reading simultaneously was to see if there were any differences in my experiences as a reader. One thing stood out to me about the digital reading:

  My digital reading was more like skimming than reading. I was coming away with a general idea of the plot, but I wasn’t developing a highly detailed memory of it. I enjoyed the book, but I didn’t find myself reading it particularly critically.

  Remember, I didn’t have to do any of this reading. I chose to do it. I picked the books myself, too. There was nothing unpleasant about any of it, and yet I found myself hurrying along, skimming over sections in a blur in a way that I did not with the other readings. Of course, reading aloud or listening to a tape limits the amount of skimming one can do (you can be inattentive with listening to a text, but you can’t skim per se, and reading aloud forces a thorough or complete processing of the words at the very least).

  Since my personal exploration of the problem, there have been many systematic studies into the issues that you raise. I didn’t find any evidence concerning different neural processing for digital and traditional reading, but I did find lots of data that should give you pause in using such texts to help teach science.

  1. You assume that kids will like using e-books because they won’t have to tote a heavy textbook. That may be true, but generally, studies seem to report that kids don’t like reading digitally as much as with traditional text (Chou, 2016; Ketron & Naletelich, 2016; Walton, 2013; Woody, 2010). Whatever you gain in happiness about a lighter backpack may be lost in terms of how kids negative feelings about this reading itself. I know in popular culture the idea is that kids love everything electronic and that they prefer to live on their screens. However, true any of that may be, it appears not to be the case when it comes to reading an extended text. We simply are not there yet (and Scholastic’s annual surveys with younger kids suggest that it might be a while before we get there).
  2. There is some research suggesting that it is a bad idea to project light into one’s eyes too close to bedtime (Chang, Aeschbach Duffy, & Czeisler, 2015). It disrupts one’s sleep and reduces next morning alertness (unlike reading the reflected light of a traditional page). Perhaps the e-book reading will be done late in the afternoon or with reversed text, but just as likely it may reduce your students’ science success—at least for those who have your class early in the day.
  3. But here is the kicker. Most studies find that your students are likely to be like me. They don’t read as well when reading digitally (Ackerman & Goldsmith, 2011; Baron, 2015; Huang, et al., 2013; Jabr, 2013; Wolf, 2008) and traditional reading is related to growth in inference making in comprehension, but digital reading experience is not (Duncan, McGeown, Griffiths, Stothard, & Dobai, 2016). Your students might be able to gain purchase on main ideas that are high in an information hierarchy in the e-books, but they can be expected to lag in learning the details that support those main ideas (Singer & Alexander, 2017). Studies also suggest that even when students comprehend digital texts almost as well as traditional texts, their memory for this information deteriorates more quickly (Garland, 2003). In other words, e-books are not likely to help your kids learn science, as well as traditional science texts, will.

  Given all of that, you’d think that I would conclude that digital texts are a bad idea.

That is not the case.

  The fact is e-books are coming. Whether you assign them now or hold off for a few years, you will eventually do so (e-book reading has a lot of benefits—ecologically, economically, factually in terms of providing up-to-date scientific information, etc.).

  If you are going to assign e-reading, then I suggest the following:

  Teach your students about the problems of e-texts and brainstorm with them how they can overcome these limitations.

  Help your students to slow down and intensify their digital reading. Provide greater amounts of scaffolding for electronic reading than you would for traditional reading.

For example, have the students take formal notes—by hand. Perhaps provide them with a structural organizer for a chapter, an organizer that graphically shows them the relations among the various ideas or concepts. Then have them record their notes within this structure and review these with the students to see if they have managed to grasp the key ideas.

  Or, provide them with questions or tasks that require them to connect the main ideas with the supporting details.

  Or, give them greater opportunity to reread and review the texts.  

  Indeed, assign e-books, but make sure that your kids can read them as well as they can read traditional science text.

Comments

See what others have to say about this topic.

Elizabeth Gates
Oct 30, 2017 12:20 AM

I cannot thank you enough for your timely and thorough response. I especially appreciate your suggestions on scaffolding with ebooks and student engagement in problem solving the issues of comprehension and memory. As you stated, they are coming, and your suggestions help in planning how to use them. Great help!

Gale Morrison
Oct 30, 2017 05:36 PM

This is wonderful thank you! I am co-founder of a parent advocacy group for math and science education in my district, and our middle school switched two years ago to Amplify Science. And, after several years our district is examining how our high school 1 to 1 iPad program has worked out and what comes next. Parents and educators are grappling with exactly what you lay out above.

ann
Oct 30, 2017 11:25 PM

Audio books (e-readers like those found on Learning Ally) are of critical importance for my dyslexic kiddos. So long as they are reading the words - following along, they are gaining the critical orthographic knowledge that they are often lacking - gaining sight words AND building vocabulary AND enjoying books that are at or above their reading/decoding ability. This has made a significant difference for my children and those I teach. Expository is trickier but equally important. That's where the note-taking is critical yet tricky as they are required to have the metacognitive sense to pause the recording and do the writing... Thanks again Timothy Shanahan

Jackie Johnson
Oct 31, 2017 01:35 PM

My school district has been holding off on e-books for student independent reading for some of the reasons you mention. They simply prefer the print copy. Yet, our textbooks are going digital. Thank you for sharing your experience with digital and suggestions for supporting student access to the content.

What Are your thoughts?

Leave me a comment and I would like to have a discussion with you!

Comment *
Name*
Email*
Website
Comments

Are E-Books a Good Idea for the Science Class?

4 comments

One of the world’s premier literacy educators.

He studies reading and writing across all ages and abilities. Feel free to contact him.