Teacher question:
I was just told that the science of reading says that we shouldn’t teach blending or that we teach too much blending and should dial it back. Do you agree with that?
Shanahan response:
Studies have long supported blending instruction as part of explicit phonics teaching (Pflaum, et al., 1980; National Reading Panel, 2000), so I don’t agree with claims that addressing blending is a bad idea.
As for reducing the amount of blending teaching? I can’t really say whether that makes sense, since I don’t know how much blending instruction is currently offered or who is receiving it and at what point in their development they’re receiving it. With tens of thousands of elementary schools and no survey data on this question, one can only guess.
I’ll give you my take on the issue but first let’s look at how blending is usually addressed. Phonics instruction is often divided into two types, and each deal with blending differently.
Synthetic phonics begins with individual letters (graphemes) and sounds (phonemes). Let’s say the students are taught the phonemes for the letters a, b, and d. Knowing those letters and sounds should allow a student to read or spell a word like bad.
Things don’t always work that way. Instead of “bad,” the result is often something more like, “buh, ah, duh,” leaving students perplexed. That isn’t reading.
There’s an unfortunate gap between what we’re trying to teach and what students may end up with. It’s kind of like the difference between talking and singing. Instead of producing a bunch of separate words, singers glide from word to word. Analogously, beginning readers shouldn’t produce a series of separate phonemes. They need to glide from one sound to the other so that they end up with words and not a string of noises.
That’s where blending instruction comes into play in synthetic phonics. The idea is to guide kids to do that gliding and to make those connections between phonemes.
The problem is that there’s no way to produce consonant phonemes without adding vowel sounds. They cannot be produced in isolation, so teaching kids a string of isolated letters and sounds, guarantees that you’ll end up with extra vowels.
Teachers wisely try to minimize it by minimizing the extra vowel sounds – making them as small as possible. That helps, but it doesn’t necessarily solve the problem. Even when you minimize those pronunciations CVC words too often end up with 5 phonemes instead of 3.
An approach that I used when teaching first grade was to model blending; showing students how I’d transform a string of phonemes into a word’s pronunciation. I think that helped. My classes also did a lot of writing from the beginning. I suspect that mattered too. When youngsters try to write words, going from sounds to letters, they gain valuable insights into how the letters and sounds relate to each other in words.
An approach that has research behind is what is referred to as “connected phonation” (Gonzalez-Frey & Ehri, 2020). The basic idea is to teach kids to sound out words without breaking the speech flow. Kids are taught to stretch the sounds to make connecting them easier (“/sssss/aaaaa/ddddd/).
The term “connected phonation” is a recent addition to our instructional jargon, but various versions of the approach have been around for a long time. For example, teachers have encouraged kids to say the sounds faster – lessening the distance between the phonemes—or, to “bulldoze the sounds,” banging them together (Brown, 2003).
The other type of phonics instruction is analytic phonics. There are various versions of this approach. Analytic phonics doesn’t teach blending as much as it tries to limit the need for it.
Two hundred years ago, syllables were introduced in beginning reading instruction almost immediately after letters and sounds. They weren’t teaching kids how to separate words into their separate syllables. No, they were having kids memorize and read common syllables: ba, be, bi, bo, bu, by, ab, eb, ib, ob, ub, etc. Teaching the pronunciation of these combinations reduces the likelihood that kids would have trouble blending, and that’s one of the reasons that some modern-day authorities encourage this kind of syllable teaching (Groff, 1981).
A more recent version of analytic phonics focuses on what linguists refer to as onsets and rimes (Goswami, 1994, 1999, 2002). The rime is the vowel part of the syllable along with any following consonants, like the at in cat. Putting less attention on individual phonemes and getting students to focus on larger chunks within words reduces the need for blending and, consequently, for blending instruction.
An approach to analytic phonics that I was taught when I was becoming a teacher, starts not with letters and sounds but with word memorization. The idea is that if students know words like “big” and “had,” then they should be able to read a word like “bad” by analogy, drawing the onset from one word and the rime from another. (I wonder if decodable texts play a similar role these days, exposing children to repeatable patterns that are not necessarily recognized nor read letter by letter).
I’ve never heard those who argue for supplementing phonics with morphology instruction claim it would reduce blending problems, but it seems obvious that any approach that stresses larger units of pronunciation within words would help with this.
These analytic approaches may seem cumbersome, but the National Reading Panel (2001) concluded that they worked. There were fewer studies of analytic phonics than of synthetic phonics, and their average effect size was a bit lower (though not significantly so). Nevertheless, synthetic and analytic phonics both provided kids with learning advantages.
I’ve written about this before (Shanahan, 2018). I thought some of my students were confused by trying to decode words by analogy. It was just too complicated for some of them. I added some synthetic phonics to the mix and found that it helped them to do fine. I have no doubt that if kids in a synthetic phonics program had trouble with blending, then the teaching of some larger word units (rimes, syllables, multi-letter morphemes) could help.
As a teacher, I wondered why the professors thought it was so important to separate synthetic and analytic phonics instruction. My experiences led me to believe that they could be combined in ways that helped kids to think about words more effectively.
My answers to your questions?
Problems with blending may arise for children when they’re first learning to decode, and this is especially apparent during the phase when they’re learning the relations between letters (individual letters or digraphs like sh or ng) and individual phonemes. Research shows that explicit instruction in blending – such as connected phonation – can solve the problem.
But like anything, it would be possible to overdo it. Kids only need that kind of instructional support until they can do it reasonably well – which usually doesn’t take very long. One way to minimize the problem is to get to larger units of pronunciation like rimes or morphemes early on. Those support kids blending progress, too.
References
Brown, K. J. (2003). What do I say when they get stuck on a word? Aligning teachers’ prompts with students’ development. Reading Teacher, 56(8), 720-733.
Gonzalez-Frey, S. M., & Ehri, L. C. (2021). Connected phonation is more effective than segmented phonation for teaching beginning readers to decode unfamiliar words. Scientific Studies of Reading, 25(3), 272–285. https://doi.org/10.1080/10888438.2020.1776290\
Goswami, U. (1994). Phonological skills, analogies, and reading development. Reading, 28(2), 32-37. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-9345.1994.tb00834.xDigital Object Identifier (DOI)
Goswami, U. (1999). Causal connections in beginning reading: The importance of rhyme. Journal of Research in Reading, 22(3), 217–240. https://doi.org/10.1111/1467-9817.00087
Goswami, U. (2002). Phonology, reading development, and dyslexia: A cross-linguistic perspective. Annals of Dyslexia, 52, 141-163. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11881-002-0010-0
Groff, P. (1981). Reading by syllables. Reading Teacher, 34(6), 659-664.
National Reading Panel. (2000). Teaching children to read: An evidence-based assessment of the scientific research literature on reading and its implications for reading instruction: Reports of the subgroups (NIH Publication No. 00-4754). Washington, DC: National Institute of Child Health and Human Development.
Pflaum, S. W., Walberg, H. J., Karegianes, M. L., & Rasher, S. P. (1980). Reading instruction: A quantitative analysis. Educational Researcher, 9(7), 12-18.
https://doi.org/10.3102/0013189X00900701
Shanahan, T. (2018, February 4). Which is best? Analytic or synthetic phonics? Shanahan on Literacy. https://www.shanahanonliteracy.com/blog/which-is-best-analytic-or-synthetic-phonics
Stanback, M. L. (1992). Syllable and rime patterns for teaching reading: Analysis of a frequency-based vocabulary of 17,602 words. Annals of Dyslexia, 42, 196-221. https://www.jstor.org/stable/23768001
Torgersen, C. J., Brooks, G., & Hall, J. (2006). A systematic review of the research literature on the use of phonics in the teaching of reading and spelling. Sheffield, UK: University of Sheffield.
Comments
See what others have to say about this topic.